Paper Review Comments To Author

Be constructive if possible by suggesting improvements.

Paper review comments to author. Regarding the figures. The review process should help you to improve your paper. In this section write a detailed report reviewing the different parts of the manuscript.

Reviewer comments and responses reviewer 1 comment. This is a prospective study that analyzed the factors associated with cancer progression after emr of barrett s esophagus with high grade dysplasia. Once i submitted a paper to a very famous journal.

I recommend removing fig. Everybody makes mistakes so do not be disheartened. Such introductions are good psychology if you want the author to drastically revise the paper.

Recommended if the review is critical. Accept manuscript in its current form publish with minor changes publish only if major improvements are made or to reject the paper. What is a review article.

Don t be so negative that the author ends up pulling apart her entire paper. Eighty patients underwent emr and were followed every 3 months for 1 year and every 6 months thereafter for 3 years. Sample peer review of a fictitious manuscript reviewer a s comments to authors.

Click to enlarge and share. I am so embarrassed i will just withdraw my paper. Comments for both the editor and authors.