Paper Review Comments Sample

Comments and suggestion are listed in the next section.

Paper review comments sample. With modifications addressing the detailed comments below and better recognizing the complexity of the current data publication landscape this will be a worthwhile review paper. Overall though this is a timely and needed essay. Minor comments please refer to the comments in the edited manuscript file for minor comments.

Because of this the review should be more than a simple accept or reject. Sample review comments serve the purpose of guiding a person drafting a performance review so that they can frame the performance appraisal letter correctly. Below are the types of assignments we review along with sample feedback.

I recommend removing fig. There was clear scientific and. It is well researched and nicely written with rich metaphor.

This should only be about 10 of your overall essay. In a paragraph summarize the main points of the article as well as your opinions about its significance accuracy and clarity. Feedback will vary among writing instructors but will consist of some of these.

Detailed comments for author s please enter your comments for the author s giving your reasons for accepting or rejecting the. The corresponding changes and refinements made in the revised paper are summarized in our response below. We have carefully addressed all the comments.

When writing a review you should describe the reasons for the recommendation so that the editor can make an informed decision. See how the author has integrated the summary and evaluation through the use of evaluative terms and phrases. Note that these sample paper reviews have not yet been updated for apa 7 changes.