Journal Paper Review Comments Sample

When i was invited to review a manuscript by journal editors i will try to use whatever online template given by them.

Journal paper review comments sample. Major comments to publish this paper in your target journal the following revisions are strongly advised. Remarks to the authors section for providing comments and suggestions for the authors and the. Whether you re publishing a journal article review or completing one for a class your critique should be fair thorough and constructive.

A paper submitted to the journal is reviewed anonymously by independent experts in the field peers. This guide includes information on the writing center s one on one paper review service. Check the journal s guidelines or with the journal editor.

Evaluate the main points and arguments in the article. The literature review was thorough the methodology was painstakingly thorough and incorporated the use of sufficient numbers of samples in dust size analysis and explosion tests. I recommend removing fig.

Reviewer comments and responses reviewer 1 comment. Check the journal s aims and scope. Reviewer s blind review comments to author.

Once you have the core review section written take a step back and look for common trends that emerge. Minor comments please refer to the comments in the edited manuscript file for minor comments. Giving an effective peer review.

There was clear scientific and. Open education resources for academic writing. Skim the article to get a feel for its organization read it multiple times and jot down notes and comments during the process.